Monday, March 18, 2013

The Great Cypriot Game - How important is gas to Cyprus' economic and geopolitical future?

Update 12:00 18/03/13:

Russian Finance Minister Anton Siluanov has had some interesting things to say on the deposit levy (via Reuters):

"We had an agreement with colleagues from the euro zone that we'll coordinate our actions."

"It turns out that the euro zone actions on the introduction of the deposit levy took place without discussions with Russia, so we will consider the issue of restructurisation of the (Cyprus) loan taking into account our participation in the joint actions with the European Union to help Cyprus."
It seems Russia is none too happy with the eurozone approach, unsurprisingly. If it does refuse to ease the terms of the €2.5bn bailout loan it previously gave Cyprus, it could hit Cypriot funding requirements, although probably not by a substantial amount. Still it could result in eurozone bailout funds being used to pay off a Russian loan in the near future - something which may not sit well with German taxpayers. Again, the interesting fall out will be to see how this impacts Russia's approach to Cyprus and the EU more broadly.

***************** Original post ********************************

In the middle ages, Cyprus was a key battle ground between great powers seeking dominance in the region. Well, the country - which, remember, only accounts for 0.2% of eurozone GDP - could become a hotspot once more (though we shouldn't be over-excited about this).

According Greek Reporter, Gazprom made an offer over the weekend to the Cypriot government to fund the bank restructuring planned under the Cypriot bailout (which is set to cost up to €10bn) in exchange for exclusive exploration rights for Cypriot territorial waters. How reliable this story is remains to be seen, but it does hint at the geopolitical tension which we have been warning about.

Gazprom is known to be very close to the Russian government and despite Russian President Vladimir Putin overtly slamming the deposit tax - calling it "unfair, unprofessional and dangerous" -  it is unlikely that they would let this opportunity pass untouched. Fortunately, the Cypriot government is said to have rejected the deal off the bat, but if displeasure towards the eurozone and the EU grows, the Russian option may become increasingly appealing.

So how important is the gas element for Cyprus' economic and geopolitical future? Well, there is no denying that Cyprus could potentially be sitting on top of gas reserves worth many times its GDP. However, as a revenue stream it is far from a sure thing. Here is how we put it in our flash analysis released on Friday:
Recent exploration has suggested Cyprus may have between €18.5bn and €29.5bn (103% - 163% of GDP) in untapped gas reserves lying in its territorial waters (according to Deutsche Bank). There have been rumours that this future revenue stream could be incorporated or used to backstop the bailout somehow. Although an appealing idea, there is still a huge amount of uncertainty around the real value of these reserves and how soon they can begin producing revenue
So far, one field has been explored (known as Block 12) and estimates of its potential value go as high as €100bn. See below for a useful diagram (via Baker Tilley):


However, there are a few key points to remember when considering the impact of this on the Cypriot bailout:
  • Exports from the gas fields are not expected to begin until 2019 at the earliest. Cyprus runs out of cash in June this year, a short and medium term solution is needed now. Tapping the further reserves (beyond Block 12) will take even longer.
  • There needs to be significant investment, potentially up to $4bn to begin extracting the gas – the Cypriot government certainly cannot afford this. Although there is sizeable interest in the exploration rights, the FT’s Nick Butler notes that Noble Energy (which explored Block 12) is not bidding for further rights, which raises some concerns.
  • Furthermore, Turkey is still contesting Cyprus’ ownership of these reserves. Although Cyprus currently has the backing of the international community, this dispute could further hold up progress in tapping these reserves. Many of the energy companies looking into Cyprus also have interests in Turkey and may not want to put those at risk.
To us then, the offer by the Cypriot government to provide Cypriot depositors with bonds linked to gas revenues sounds like a nice idea, but will not compensate these depositors for some years, at best.

But, remember with a view to Moscow, this is definitely one to watch.

6 comments:

Anonymous said...

Looks to me as if much of the gas should actually be in British water? Does Britain not claim sovereignty over the water surrounding their bases?

Rollo said...

Extremely dangerous to let the oligarchs have your future mineral rights.

Rik said...

Should have put the concessions in a vehicle (give it a taxconcession as well to increase future CF and subsequently the valuation) and do an IPO. Act if you sell to Gazprom to put pressure on the other side. The whole circus would probably not have been necessary.
Like with the rest of them you could have seen this one coming for 2 years and they simply wait till things go wrong.

Anonymous said...

NEVER NEVER

Anonymous said...

Does Britain not claim sovereignty over the water surrounding their bases?

Start first with ...Scotland. I have infos that your bases are gonna be sold to ...russian's oligarchs.
You are so funny.

Anonymous said...

Take the money and be free of the IMF and the EU. No other entity has offered to pay for the exploration/exploitation other than Gazprom. The 10billion is an 'earnest' payment against future royalties. The UK is never going to pay for exploration. In the end of the day if a lot of gas/oil found, Cyprus can always nationalize if the Russians get too tiresome.